Weaving together historical fiction and mystery through dual timelines, this is a story that is both intense and emotionally engaging. Here is my book review The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner.

London 1791 and Present Day

Set in 18th-century London and present-day England, the novel follows Nella, a secret apothecary who sells poisons to women seeking justice against harmful men. Our present day protagonists is Caroline, a modern historian who stumbles upon clues to Nella’s past. Penner’s vivid descriptions of the apothecary shop and its hidden world make me think about a movie set in the making, drawing readers into a richly imagined, dangerous world.

Female Oppression Then and Now

One of the novel’s strengths lies in its exploration of female agency and the ways women navigate oppression across different eras. Nella’s story is compelling and morally complex, raising questions about justice and revenge, while her young protege Eliza’s involvement adds an element of curiosity and coming-of-age tension. In contrast, Caroline’s modern storyline highlights themes of self-discovery and personal reinvention, as she realizes she has put her dreams on hold for her husband. Though a bit predictable, the alternating timelines are engaging.

Debut

I enjoyed this book and it’s very good given it is Penner’s debut novel. The blending of mystery and magic with historical intrigue and feminist themes is reminiscent of early works by V.E. Schwab. Fans of historical fiction with a touch of suspense will likely appreciate Penner’s storytelling and the haunting world she brings to life.

Thank you for reading my book review The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner. Four stars for The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner. See last week’s book review Intrepid Girls: The Complicated History of the Girl Scouts of the USA by Amy Erdman Farrell.

We are always grateful when you pin, share and comment on our book reviews. Thank you.